| Contestant | Original Tribe | Merged Tribe | Finish |
| Jimmy Patterson, 63 | Tortuga | 1st Voted Out Day 3 | |
| Michelle Adams, 25 | Aguila | 2nd Voted Out Day 6 | |
| Stacey Yukosi, 38 | Tortuga | 3rd Voted Out Day 9 | |
| Ashley Santanas, 23 | Aguila | 4th Voted Out Day 12 | |
| Taylor Parsons,26 | Aguila | Tiburon | |
| Jacob Tirrsky, 29 | Aguila | ||
| Alex Mason, 21 | Aguila | ||
| Caleb Jackson, 27 | Aguila | ||
| Joey Gauder, 35 | Tortuga | ||
| Katie Utiopo, 28 | Tortuga | ||
| George Lopez, 51 | Tortuga | ||
| Hannah Tonners, 27 | Tortuga |